I Reread My Commonplace Book for Years. Nothing Happened.

Before I built Ember, my commonplace book lived in Evernote. I remember scrolling through the quotes I’d saved from Creativity, Inc. — Ed Catmull’s ideas on candor and creativity, lines I’d pulled out because they’d stopped me mid-page. Rereading them, I remember the feeling exactly: inspired. Warm. Like visiting old friends.

And then I closed the app. And nothing happened.

I did this for years. For every book I read, I had a notebook of quotes in Evernote, and I’d go back and reread them. I’d feel that glow. But it kind of just stopped there. All that collected wisdom — perfectly preserved, searchable, organized — functioning as decoration.

It took me a long time to find the physics for what was happening.

The first law of commonplace books

Isaac Newton’s First Law of Motion: an object at rest stays at rest, and an object in motion stays in motion… unless acted upon by an unbalanced force.

That’s it. That’s the diagnosis. An object at rest stays at rest. My quotes weren’t dead — they were dormant. Full of potential energy, waiting on a force that never arrived.

Because here’s the thing: rereading isn’t a force. Rereading is admiring the object at rest. The unbalanced force is writing — the rhythm of writing about the ideas you’ve saved, and writing from them.

And your mind is ready for the collision in a way it wasn’t before. Since the first time you experienced those quotes, your brain has changed — even from yesterday to today. It has new information. New ideas. The moment your changed mind bumps up against an old quote, something unlocks. Maybe you see something you haven’t seen before. Maybe you think something you’ve never thought.

But only if there’s contact. Only if you write.

The mastermind

This is what it looks like now. I open a thinking session in Ember and start writing about something — say, patience. And my commonplace book chimes in. A line from Marcus Aurelius pulls up a chair. Next to him, something I saved from Morgan Housel last Tuesday. A proverb I copied out years ago leans in from across the table.

The ideas are talking to each other. People I admire — from yesterday to two thousand years ago — showing up in the same session. It’s almost like a mastermind.

They chime in. They chime in.

And the epiphanies arrive uninvited. Most of the time nothing comes to me for a specific work problem or anything like that — there’s just a revelation of something I didn’t know before, and that excites me. That happens all the time now. It never happened when I was only rereading.

Why we stop at inspired

What might be holding you back from engaging more deeply with your commonplace book and its ideas?

I think most of us stop at inspired because inspired feels like the finish line. The glow is real. It just isn’t motion.

You can’t expect to grow if you’re not engaging with the ideas by writing about them and writing from them. A commonplace book is, at its simplest, a book of quotes — already powerful, because it’s unique and curated by you. But the power multiplies when you write.

So here’s the one thing to try: tomorrow morning, open your commonplace book, pick one quote, and use it as the prompt for your journal. Write from it and see what happens.

Maybe you’ll land on something you’ve been trying to solve at work, or at home. Maybe you’ll just have a moment of deeper thought that excites you. Either way, the object is in motion now — and an object in motion stays in motion.

Everyone should write. Why? Because everyone is full of ideas they’re not aware of. This means they’re also unaware of the value of their ideas, and this value can only be unlocked via writing. — Morgan Housel

A journal and a book of quotes is all you need to start. And if you want a place built for exactly this — where your saved ideas chime in while you think — that’s why I made Ember. Start a thinking session and let your commonplace book pull up a chair.

Thanks for reading The Idea Shepherd! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.