‘Little red dots’ could herald the birth of supermassive black holes

Newborn and rapidly growing supermassive black holes could be powering the mysterious “little red dots” that litter the early universe. That is the conclusion of an international team of astronomers who have found the best evidence yet for a new kind of object called a “black-hole star”, which appears to be driving a little red dot that existed just 660 million years after the Big Bang.

“A little red dot is an extraordinary object,” says team leader Rohan Naidu, of the University of Hawaii and MIT. “Somewhere within it lies a black-hole star, surrounded by a good old fashioned galaxy.”

When the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) began observing the distant universe in the summer of 2022, astronomers were astonished to find lots of little red dots. They are highly luminous as one would expect an active black hole to be, but their spectra are odd, looking more like stars with no X-ray emission.

Some astronomers believe little red dots are dense cocoons of gas incubating a growing black hole at their cores. As the black hole accretes gas from the interior of the cocoon, it radiates energy that is absorbed by the cocoon – making it glow brightly. This is similar to how stars shine, the radiation from their core heating their outer layers. Hence these hypothesized objects are dubbed black-hole stars.

Until now, however there had only been circumstantial evidence for this hypothesis. Part of the problem is that in most cases the light from the little red dots mingles with the light from the unresolved host galaxy, clouding the observations.

Miracle or mirage?

Naidu is co-lead of the Mirage or Miracle (MoM) survey. When pushing to high redshifts (further distances) with the JWST, it can be difficult to discern whether a faint red splotch is really a high-redshift galaxy or a cool star in the foreground masquerading as something from the early universe.

Now, MoM has found a black-hole star shining 100 billion times brighter than any known star, and drastically outshining its host galaxy.

Called MoM-BH*-1, the object is incredibly luminous at longer wavelengths, but below the wavelength corresponding to the Balmer series of hydrogen emission there is no light at all. This sudden drop in luminosity is called the Balmer break and is often seen in young stars.

“In MoM-BH*-1 the Balmer break is three to four times stronger than any we’ve seen ever before,” says Naidu. “This feature alone tells us there is something truly singular afoot, and that this is a new kind of astrophysical object.”

Extremely dense cocoon

Simulations modelling the Balmer break and the object’s luminosity strongly suggest that there is a 100,000 solar mass black hole at the centre of MoM-BH*-1, surrounded by an extremely dense cocoon of gas.

“The physics of how its light is being produced by this dense gas cocoon around this black hole is radically different from what we see around us in the local universe,” says Naidu.

If the object is indeed a black-hole star, a salient question is how did the black hole form? Numerous possibilities have been raised, from the direct gravitational collapse of a gas cloud to the merger of a cluster of massive stars.

Naidu favours an explanation involving a supermassive star – an object that could have formed about 150 million years after the Big Bang when the universe was dense with hydrogen and helium. According to many popular models, these conditions spawned stars thousands of times the mass of the Sun.

Recent outburst

Naidu points to the life cycles of the massive stars in the Milky Way, which top out at a few hundred solar masses. Eta Carinae, for example, had an outburst in the 1840s that made it the second brightest star in the sky for several days. The outburst from this 100-solar-mass star left a cocoon of gas called the Homunculus Nebula. A much larger supermassive star could have had a similar outburst and then collapse to a black hole, thereby creating a black hole star.

“In the past few months I’ve seen so much evidence for this, that at this point, it is the main hypothesis that needs to be proved or disproved because the similarities to supermassive stars are uncanny,” says Naidu.

Indeed, it is possible that every supermassive black hole in the universe could be a relic of the very first giant stars created just after the Big Bang. Over time these objects would steadily erode their gaseous cocoon, eating it away from the inside-out while radiation from accretion onto the black hole would blow away the remainder of the cocoon. This is supported by a recent discovery by NASA’s Chandra X-ray Observatory of a little red dot that existed 11.8 billion years ago and from which X-rays are starting to peak through holes in its shredded cocoon.

Naidu is suitably awe-struck by the possibilities, describing how “it’s inspiring to be witnessing the birth of supermassive black holes.”

The discovery of MoM-BH*-1 is reported in Nature.

The post ‘Little red dots’ could herald the birth of supermassive black holes appeared first on Physics World.